First of all, we would like to thank you for your kind cooperation with our journal. We kindly ask you to complete your personal information carefully, especially organizational affiliation, ORCID ID, area(s) of research interest, and bank account information when creating your profile for the first time.

If a manuscript that has been sent to you for reviewing is not in your area or you do not have time to review, please inform us and suggest alternative reviewers if possible.

When reviewing manuscripts, please answer the questions on the review form and if you leave a comment on the article file, please ensure that your name is not visible in the comments.

Publication Ethics for Reviewers

We are expected that all reviewers read and follow the ethical principles of manuscript publication on this page .

Review registration in the Web of Science

In order to register review in the Web of Science database, please send the “thank you” email you receive from the journal after the review to the address: “reviews@webofscience.com”.