Effectiveness of Chemical Management for Broadleaf Weeds in Autumn-Sown Chickpea (Cicer arietinum L.)
Volume 16, Issue 1, June 2025, Pages 71-93
https://doi.org/10.22067/ijpr.2024.89397.1097
Mozhgan Veisi, Mehdi Minbashi Moeini, Sepideh Hatami, Mohammad Saleh Mansouri
Abstract Introduction
Chickpeas, with 37.8 % of the total production of pulses, ranked first in Iran and produced 168142.5 t.ha-1 in 439872 ha of area harvested. The largest area under cultivation of chickpea is located in Kermanshah, Kurdistan and Lorestan provinces in Iran. Various strategies for weed management can be used in autumn-sown chickpea, including application of interrow cultivator, crop management (crop rotations) and application of herbicides. Herbicide can be considered as one of the effective measures to reduce weed damage in chickpea. Like other pulses, chickpea is more likely damaged by post (post emergence) herbicides than PRE (pre emergence) herbicides. This indicates the limitations of herbicides, especially post-emergence herbicides for broadleaf weeds in chickpeas. Ccurrently, only few herbicides are recommended for chickpea in Iran. Farmers in Iran prefer to manage weeds, by hand weeding or using cultivator between rows, due to potential risk of herbicide damages, high cost involved in herbicide applications, and limited herbicide options for selective weed control. Considering the wide range of weed species in chickpeas in different regions of Iran, autumn-sown requires herbicides that provide a broader spectrum of weed control. Furthermore, the preventing of weed resistance to herbicides makes it necessary to increase the diversity of herbicides. In this regard, the purpose of this study was to compare new PRE-herbicide (flumioxazin) with different rates as IBS, PRE, and early-post with previously used herbicides, in terms of weed control and subsequently increase grain yield of chickpea.
Materials and Methods
This experiment was carried out in Kermanshah, West Azerbaijan and Hamadan during crop year 2021-2022, Iran. The experiment was laid out in a randomized complete block design (RCBD) with 12 treatments and four replicates. Treatments included pre-emergence (PRE) application of novagap (aclonifen 600 SC) at 1, 2, 3 and 4 l.ha-1, oxyfluorfen (SC 24%) at 0.7 l.ha-1, clean sheet (flumioxazin, WP 50%) at100 g.ha-1, post-emergence (POST) application of aclonifen at 1, 1.5, 2 and 2.5 l.ha-1, PRE application of oxyfluorfen at 0.7 l.ha-1+POST application of aclonifen at 1.5 l.ha-1 and hand weeding. 30 days after post-emergence spraying, density and dry weight of weeds per plot were determined and compared with untreated control. At harvesting, grain yield, plant height and dry weight of chickpea was measured per unit area. Variance analysis of chickpea data was also done through SAS software, and then the averages were compared based on Duncan's test (p<0.05).
Results and Discussion
At kermanshah visual evaluation results showed that the highest reduction in weeds (87 to 90%) was observed in PRE application of aclonifen at 2, 3 and 4 l.ha-1 and flumioxazin without any significant difference. In addition, PRE application of aclonifen 2 l.ha-1 had a very good efficiency (91-100%) in reducing the density and dry weight of weeds of R. rugosum, C. album and C. orientalis. Also, C. intybus and C. oxycantha were controlled by this treatment with a lower percentage (72-81%). The highest grain yields of chickpea in Kermanshah (590.5 to 609 kg.ha-1) was observed in the PRE aclonifen at 2 and 3 l. ha-1 that had no significant difference with hand weeding. At Hamadan, the highest weed control efficiency (95%) found in aclonifen at 2, 3 and 4 l.ha-1, flumioxazin, oxyflourfen and oxyfluorfen + aclonifen. The results in Hamedan showed that flumioxazin, post aclonifen 2.5 l.ha-1 and PRE aclonifen 2, 3 and 4 l.ha-1, oxyfluorfen and oxyfluorfen + aclonifen favorably reduced the density of D. Sophia, Alyssum spp. and total weeds. In the visual evaluation, the highest efficiency belonged to aclonifen at 4 l.ha-1, followed by PRE aclonifen at 2 and 3 l. ha-1, flumioxazin and oxyfluorfen + aclonifen. At Hamedan, PRE aclonifen at 2 l. ha-1 and flumioxazin had the highest grain yield of chickpea with 309 and 322 kg.ha-1, respectively, and there was no statistically significant difference with each other and hand weeding treatment. At West Azerbayjan, the highest weed control (84 to 86%) belonged to a PRE application of aclonifen at 3 and 4 l.ha-1 and POST application of aclonifen at 2.5 l.ha-1 that there was no significant difference between them. At West Azerbayjan, after hand weeding, aclonifen 3 l. ha-1 and flumioxazin had the highest grain yield of chickpea with 1251 and 1254 kg.ha-1, respectively.
Conclusions
According to the results, aclonifen is recommended as a pre-emergence application at 2 to 3 l.ha-1 and flumioxazin at 100 g.ha-1 for the control of broadleaf weeds in rainfed autumn- sown chickpea.
Effects of limited irrigation and herbicide on yield, yield components and water consumption of beans (Phaseolus vulgaris L.)
Volume 14, Issue 1, June 2023, Pages 146-159
https://doi.org/10.22067/ijpr.v14i1.2210-1046
Seyed Hossein Nazer Kakhki, Samira Vahedi, Masoud Kamel Shikhraje
Abstract Introduction
The effectiveness of productivity and sustainable agricultural development depends on the availability of natural resources as well as the efficiency of management measures in agricultural lands. Increasing water use efficiency is a promising way to manage agricultural production in arid and semi-arid regions where there is little or no prospect of expanding water resources (Boutraa, 2010). According to Malik et al. (1993) bean yield may be reduced up to 70% when faced in competition with weeds. Extending the irrigation cycle (limited irrigation) in beans is expected to diminish not only the water consumption but also to influence the weed density along with dry matter too.
Materials and Methods
This project was conducted at Khair-abad research station in Zanjan, Iran, over a period of two years starting from the 2017 growing season. The experimental design utilized a randomized complete block design (RCBD) with 24 treatments and three replications. The treatments were arranged in a strip plot layout. The vertical factor of the experiment consisted of three levels of irrigation intervals: efficient irrigation (every 4 days), limited irrigation (every 9 days), and more limited irrigation (every 12 days). The horizontal factor involved eight sub-factors of herbicides: Trifloraline, Imazethapyr, Trifloraline + Bentazone, Imazethapyr + Bentazone, Imazethapyr + Sitogate, Bentazon + Gallant Super, traditional hand mowing, and a test sub-factor with no control. Several traits were evaluated in this study, including the number of pods, number of seeds per pod, 100-seed weight, bean grain yield, biological yield, harvest index, and productivity index. Data analysis and mean comparisons were performed using the SAS statistical software, employing Duncan's multiple range tests.
Results and Discussion
The Results indicated that both the herbicides and irrigation periods were effective on density and dry matter of weeds. Reducing irrigation intervals will allow for greater control of weed density and dry matter. Imazethapyr and Trifloraline herbicides as pre-emergence and pre-plant followed by post emergence application of Bentazone leads to about 85 and 82 % reduction at in weeds density at bean 3rd three leaflet appearance stage, 85 and 82 % reduction at 50% flowering stage bean in tow year of the study recorded the most reduction on weeds density. Moreover, these herbicides inducing about 88 and 81% decrease at bean 3rd three leaflets and 91 and 87% decrease at bean 50% flowering stage. These treatments after weeding had the highest control on weed density and dry matter. Trifloraline, when applied as a pre-plant treatment, showed the lowest effectiveness in controlling weeds among all the treatments. It resulted in an average reduction of 49% at the appearance of the bean's third three leaflets and approximately 70% reduction at the 50% flowering stage of the bean plant. This treatment consistently ranked the lowest in terms of weed control throughout the study period. The treatments of Imazethapyr, whether applied solely as a pre-emergence treatment or in combination with Situgate as a post-emergence treatment, were found to be ineffective in controlling weeds. Therefore, these treatments are not recommended for weed management in beans, particularly under limited irrigation regimes. The maximum number of sheaths, grains per sheath, and weight of 100 grains were observed in the irrigation regime of every 4 days when integrated with the application of Trifloraline, traditional hand mowing, Imazethapyr + Situgate, and Imazethapyr alone. In terms of bean harvest, the highest yields of 5175 kg/ha, 4707 kg/ha, and 4624 kg/ha were obtained from the irrigation regime of every 4 days when integrated with traditional hand mowing, the application of Imazethapyr + Bentazone, and Imazethapyr + Situgate, respectively. On the other hand the best biological performance as 9950, 9783, and 9733 kg/ha were related to 4 days interval when integrated with application of Imazethapyr + Bentazone, hand mowing, and Imazethapyr + Situgate. The maximum bean harvest index at 52.82 and 50.80 percent were related to 4 and 9 days intervals integrated with hand mowing, followed by 50.54 percent related to 4 days round integrated with Imazethapyr and 9 days round integrated with Trifloraline+ Bentazone. The highest water efficiency as 0.83 was related to 9 days interval whereas the lowest one as 0.48 was related to 4 days round. Regarding the horizontal factors, during the two years study the maximum water efficiency as 0.86, 0.77, and 0.76 were registered at treatments of hand mowing, application of combined Imazethapyr + Bentazone, and combined Imazethapyr + Situgate, respectively.
Conclusion
Based on the overall results and considering water shortage as well as water usage efficiency and decreasing the amount of both performance and traits of performance reduction in Chiti bean "Kosha" leading to desirable weeds control and bean yield, nine days round irrigation could be recommended provided with application of Imazethapyr or trifloraline herbicides with Bentazone.
Analysis of the limiting factors of pea (Pisum sativum L.) yield in the Mediterranean conditions, case study: Gonbad Kavus
Volume 12, Issue 2, December 2021, Pages 122-135
https://doi.org/10.22067/ijpr.v12i2.84317
Bahram Kamali, Ali Rahemi Karizaki, Abbas Biabani, Mahdi Mollashahi
Abstract Introduction
Pulses play an important role in supplying human food and are a major source of protein in developing countries, so they have a special role in producing food in these countries. Peas (Pisum sativum L.) belongs to legume family and is well adapted to the cold climate. This plant has a lot of crude protein and starch and is therefore high in energy. Evaluating the status of pulses production is essential because of their importance in feeding the people of the world and their role in the design of cultivation patterns. Eliminating the gap between the yield currently achieved on farms and the yield that can be achieved by using the best environmentally adapted varieties and the optimum water, soil and plant management techniques is a key strategy to overcome the nutritional challenge of a growing global population. In recent years, due to concerns about food safety issues, studies on the issue of yield gap have also been increasing worldwide and it is necessary to estimate the yield gap and its causes using appropriate methods. Therefore, the present study was conducted to determine the yield gap of peas and determine the limiting factors and their contribution to the yield gap in pea farms in Gonbad kavus.
Materials and Methods
This study was carried out in pea farms (40 farms) during 2017-18 in Gonbad Kavus, Golestan province. The required information about farms was completed through observation, questioning of farmers or measurement. Information on soil properties was obtained using digital maps available at the Agricultural Jihad Office of Gonbad Kavus. Comparative performance analysis (CPA) method was used to determine the yield gap rate and to identify its causes. In this method, the relationship between all measured variables (quantitative and qualitative) and yield was evaluated using multiple regression. In this section, first, we used stepwise method to determine which variables should be included in the final production model. The average yield was calculated by placing the observed variables (x) of the studied farms in the yield model. The maximum yield obtained was then calculated by placing the best observed value of the variables in the model. The discrepancy between these two functions was considered as the performance gap. The ratio of yield gap for each variable to total yield gap represents its contribution in the yield gap and was expressed as a percentage.
Results and Discussion
The actual and potential yield calculated by the model were estimated to be 7941 and 17708 kg/ha, respectively, and yield gap was 10078.7 kg/ha. The reasons for this yield gap were as follows: Seed rate (19.56%), Nitrogen rate (17.04%), Frequency of herbicide application (15.02%), amount of available potassium in soil (34 (13%), soil organic matter (12.81%), amount of available phosphorus in soil (11.87%), farmer experience (10.36%). Therefore, it seems that with proper management of farms and taking into account the yield gap factors mentioned above, the yield of peas in Gonbad kavus can be increased to about 10078.7 kg/ha in comparison with current yield.
Conclusion
Based on the results in 40 farms studied, out of 45 variables studied, the final model was selected with seven independent variables. In the yield model, the actual and potential yield of farms calculated by the model were 7941 and 17708 kg/ha, respectively, and the yield gap was 10078.7 kg/ha. The recommendations of this research are based on the findings of the mentioned years in the region. Obviously, these recommendations may change in the future with changing farming systems (such as extension of conservation agriculture), agricultural management and possibly climatic conditions. In addition, by modifying the first-order causing factors of the yield gap discussed in this study, the second-order factors will emerge. Therefore, monitoring and evaluation of crop management in farms should be carried out on a continuous basis and the yield gap and its causes identified and resolved. In this study, among all the common agricultural management of farms, the cases that have the most impact on the yield gap and need to be modified and improved in the first stage are identified.
